Day Dreams

A Brain, A Brain and A Kookie person. It used to mean something. Now its out of controle +) Our only hope is Blue

Tuesday, July 18, 2006

Political Post

JL has posted on the inacceptable human cost of the conflict in Lebanon right now. I think it was a great idea of her. Although I hate posting about politics and I even almost dislike all politicized people. I have something to say.

JL was right to point out that civilians were dieing, all of them innocent. Indeed, in the last 7 days, 240 Lebanese people were killed. 850 wounded, 1/2 million lost their homes. Lebanon, where the civil war stopped in 1990 and which has rebuilt itself very quickly into a very lively and touristic country, has lost all the infrastructure it has built in the 15 years since the end of it's war. Just like defense minister of Israel Ameer Peretz said "We will take Lebanon 20 years backwards". I wonder if he is proud that has been achieved.

Wars are part of human history. There will always be wars. This is why it is important to have war ethics. This is not a contradiction in terms, wars should follow certain rules. Not harming civilians is one of them. In fact the Geneva convention says civilians should not even be made uncomfortable, let alone be harmed. Another principle is proportionality.

Proportionality : Well the word is clear. I don't need to explain it. What is happening today in Lebanon violates this idea. The Lebanese attack was against a military facility. 2 soldiers were taken prisoner. 2 **soldiers**. The response was the above mentioned damage to **civilians**.

As Spain, Norway and France have pointed out, this is a disproportionate answer.

The point I wish to make is this. Why is the world tolerating this? Big countries, in my understanding, are supposed to fairly police the world in order to keep things better. This brings me to my main point. We are all racists!

Yes we are. The west has never looked fairly on Arabic countries. It's first contact with them was the crusades. In that time crusaders and the mass of Europeans said that if you kill an infidel you go to heaven. Then, in the 19th century, came orientalism. Orientalism formed most of our modern views of Arabic countries. Orientalism was an industry of cliches. It is to orientalism that we owe wonderful expressions such as "sand monkey, Camel jockey, etc...". I would like to say so much more about this racist trend. Not enough place here.

Today the world is watching as people die. Whenever someone calls for a cease fire, everyone tells him to shut up. Bush has said 3 times in 3 days he is against a cease fire. However, a cease fire is a human necessity. This means one thing. We do not care Lebanese people are dieing. To us, they are Arabs and so they are human dust. Our enlightenment values do not apply to them. I think we as citizens of advances countries should face this bravely and not run away from it. We have come to the point where we do not care when people die.

Personal note:
I have 2 Lebanese friends here, they work in the same building as me, but in different disciplines. They are Vera (girl) and Maher (boy). They are both stuck in France. They can not call their family since phone lines are cut. In short they do not know if there parents, brothers and sisters, etc. are dead or alive and with the Israeli air force doing up to 50 raids on the same city in one day. Who knows. I don't. Maybe you don't need to call your family, you just get a special feeling when they die. Then you have a depression and that's the end of your active life. It's a shame. You were talented but you were born on the wrong side of the fence. And oh, an asshole who works with Maher was making fun of him the other day, like whoops your country c'est le bordel right now. C'est le bordel = It's a brothel. It means a mess in French. How nice. I am telling you we do not give a fuck, they are not human.

Whenever I say we, we=our society. I honestly think this is a fact. Our whole society is like this, our whole culture right now.


Consider signing this petition or another one you agree better with.

14 Comments:

At 2:05 PM, Blogger Jia Li said...

you are so right steli! All of this for two men! Kill all these people for two men who were not supposed to be in that area anyway.

Isreal hasn't even got half the damage, no, nothing...Lebanon has been bombed, destroyed, damaged...Isr. has bombed power stations, schools, churches, trains, even a milk factory.

every hour people are dying, lack of food, water

WHY!

Cease fire now! let these people live.

Stop Invading other countries ISR.

 
At 2:05 PM, Blogger Jia Li said...

This makes me wanta scream!

 
At 2:20 PM, Blogger Steliano Ponticos said...

Jia for 'fairness' Israel isn't invading it's destroying from the air.

I can not see how all this relates to fighting terrorism, I mean bombing a *church* they really did that this morning.

Personally I do not give a damn who wins this war. Just let it be over without any more casualties. I am very sad.

 
At 2:27 PM, Blogger Jia Li said...

and the sea...they have a blockade...Yes, I wish there was a fairy god mother who would put a end to all war

 
At 2:55 PM, Blogger Steliano Ponticos said...

I wish too, there is not. and god knows what is going to happen..

 
At 5:01 PM, Blogger Olivia said...

Oh where do I start?

Well, on JL's blog I said "There will never be peace, as long as humans exist".

I suspect the western attitude towards Arabs comes from the militant islamic not valuing human life - suicide bombers and pogroms of each other, etc. So when given that approach, what are westerners to do?
They groom their sons to take their lives and those of infidels without a second thought all in the name of Allah.

This costs Islam a lot of respect worldwide.

I make no sense probably, I got to the falling asleep part of the night. But I had more to say.

It's also a bit like two kids, one is poking and prodding and teasing the other. Every now and then the other one slaps the other in frustration, but he doesn't stop and so the other is forced to push him to the ground.

 
At 12:50 AM, Blogger Steliano Ponticos said...

Just like you, I said there will always b war. This is why we need ethics for war.

What is happening today is wrong becuase it is collective punishment of civilians. It does not help end terrorism to bomb power stations and milk factories. On the contrary, it helps create it. With the infrastructure of Lebanon now totally destroyed, even the survivors will face hardship. They will have nowhere to live and no services.

France Press agency reported that only this morning 34 Lebanese civilians died. It is now 11 in the morning in Lebanon.

I think in your metaphore, the kid who is trying to defend himself got way too angry.

 
At 3:34 AM, Blogger Lasto-adri *Blue* said...

Hizb ALLAh is calling in the name of islam.. YES.. but Lebenon is not an islamic country.. its a christian country in fact..
even Hizb ALLAH is a she'aa not Sunnah....
whatever.. for me, i do not care... i do not care at all if they are black or white... rich or poor.. arabs or not..
just CEASE FIRE NOW.. and on the spot..
people are dying already for the lack of medicne.. if not for the raining booms !!!

i was watching a tv program here for the egyptians who were able to run away from leb. ... believe it or not.. 2000 out of 25000 egyptians could return back and the rest are stuck there!!!
the transportation is ruined... food ran out.. medicen is horrible.. there is a crisis there.. and the world is watching and calling this "self defence"!!!
By God's sack what is that deuality of actions..
believe me if the boomings were as heavy over israel... just 1 day away and the whole world will stand put applying punishments on which ever country would dare...

just like iran and syria now adays..
don't we all know that the US is one of the biggest countries in the weapons industry?.. ok..
and they export it to almost every where... OK as well
then why on earth they bother is Hizb ALLAH's weapons are from iran or syria?!!
because they owe mass destruction weapons...?! .. tell me.. ain't isreal and US having it as well?!

just i can't believe people can't understand the truth that much...
it makes me wish to scream as jia as well

 
At 4:34 AM, Blogger Olivia said...

It is just like in school or society - the majority suffer for the misdeeds of the minority.

Any domestic police crackdown is the same. How do we draw the line? How do we differentiate?

It is interesting that the more modern the world becomes, the less acceptable loss of life is. Where once people were born with the knowledge they might die before they reached adulthood - through disease or war. People lived with death, but now we expect it to be preventable.

 
At 5:18 AM, Blogger Steliano Ponticos said...

Olivia this is another good analysis you are making. I agree with you again.

You ask how do we draw the line? I think the most important thing is to draw one in the first place. Even if there is a war, it should not be allowed to harm people this way.

However, I can not see how what you are saying about loss of life becoming less tolerable when in fact we are tolerating loss of life in hundreds. Almost every houre someone is dieing over there.

 
At 5:31 AM, Blogger Steliano Ponticos said...

Blue is right, in Lebanon the president is Christian. In Syria 20% of the people are Christian. Also Lebanon and Syria probably have the best women's rights record in the whole arab world. This is where the racism comes in handy. People still think "we are attacking terrorists" becuase terrorist is the same thing as arab to them. The war has been justified in this way.

What we have now is a humanitarian crisis. even if the cease fire is only for some time, it should be allowed in order for all the wounded people/children/... to be evacuated. Australia had this idea, noone listened.

 
At 5:31 AM, Blogger Steliano Ponticos said...

Thanks to you all for your opinions.

 
At 6:54 AM, Blogger Steliano Ponticos said...

Despite the relative quiet in Beirut on Tuesday, the jittery sense of desperation is getting worse. The Westerners are being evacuated, but that’s not necessarily good news for the Lebanese staying put. Once the Westerners are gone, people on the streets wonder what will hold the Israelis back. The lull in bombing, in fact, is widely seen as a deliberate break by the Israelis to allow the foreign nationals to get out.
And yet for all the press that the Western evacuation is getting, there’s another group of refugees that isn’t being noticed. Lebanon has a large population of Iraqis, Sudanese and Somalis, as well as guest workers from the Philippines and Sri Lanka, who are too poor to pay their way out. And their governments are either ineffective (Iraq, Sudan) inattentive (the Philippines, Sri Lanka) or non-existent (Somalia) to offer any resources for these people.

Outside the office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees office in east Beirut, Abdou Shafai Ismael, 38, from Sudan, has a story that contrasts sharply with that of the American tourists and students being floated to safety on Norwegian cruise ships. While they may complain about having to pay back the U.S. government for the costs of their evacuations, from the darting look in his eyes, I think Ismael would go to great lengths (perhaps questionable ones) in order to have a spot on a boat to Cyprus. Many of the 100 or so other men milling around with him probably think the same. Theirs are tales of constant flight from one crisis to another. Ismael, for example, fled Darfur in Sudan to work in Iraq, until the Americans invaded and he fled to Syria, where he was arrested for entering the country illegally. For two months, his Syrian jailors beat him every day, he said, before releasing him to go to Lebanon.”Where will I go now?” he asks. He can’t return to Sudan, where he fears Arab militias will kill him and he says he won’t go to Syria because he fears being arrested and beaten again.

Alaa Mahmoud, 42, is Iraqi, from the notorious Haifa Street in Baghdad; he’s one of about 20,000 Iraqis in Lebanon. He fled the nascent civil war in Baghdad in 2004, and now he is sick, he says, with an infection of his hip. He has no medicine and can’t work at his job as a janitor anymore. As his eyes tear up, he pleads with me to call his sister in Baghdad to tell her he is alive. At this point, he breaks down and cries.

Inside his air-conditioned office, looking out on the street where the drama plays out, Arafat Jamal, the senior regional officer for the UNHCR, tells me that in one week, 400,000 people in Lebanon — 10% of the country’s population — have been displaced. The people in the street below him will not be taken out of the country, he said, but instead moved to “safe havens” in schools in the mountains and near Tripoli in the north. He looks tired, and he should be; he’s incredibly short-staffed at the moment because the Lebanese employees of the UNHCR have fled to the mountains themselves.

But if Beirut’s poor and stateless have the U.N. to look after them, Beirut’s rich and almost-rich can look after themselves. The signs of a mass exodus of Lebanon’s wealthy class are everywhere—and telling. The city’s ATMs, which normally disburse both Lebanese pounds and American dollars, are now only spitting out the brightly colored pounds, a sign that those who could have already fled — and took their hard currency with them. I took out 1 million pounds today, about $670, but I worry about how long that will last. Even the Western Union is unable to give out dollars.

At least credit cards still work. An upscale supermarket was packed as I stocked up for what might be a long siege of Lebanon. I found myself in a grim race with another man grabbing bottles of orange juice, each of us trying to get as many as we could before the other could claim them. This will be a savage place in two weeks if this keeps up, I thought.

We’re already seeing the beginning of shortages. Bread is hard to find, for example. And the scratch cards to recharge our mobile phone accounts — already outrageously expensive in peacetime — have jumped in price from about $40 to $50 for 80 minutes of talk-time. Soon, even that connection to the outside world will vanish.

As it is, Lebanon is already disappearing before my eyes.
A more in-depth piece on the Third World refugees I did for the San Francisco

 
At 6:54 AM, Blogger Steliano Ponticos said...

article form time magazine above

 

Post a Comment

<< Home